Costs of Home Hemodialysis Offset by Better Health, Fewer HospitalizationsDaily hemodialysis administered in patients' homes is associated with better health outcomes compared with the other in-home dialysis option: peritoneal dialysis. That's the finding of physicians at a health maintenance organization in southern California as reported in the October issue of the American Journal of Kidney Diseases, the official journal of the National Kidney Foundation.
As a result, the extra cost of providing in-home hemodialysis is balanced by lower expenditures for medications and hospital admissions.
In hemodialysis, blood is pumped out of the patient's body to an artificial kidney machine where the blood is filtered through a special membrane, called a dialyzer, and then returned to the body.
In peritoneal dialysis, the inside lining of the patient's own belly acts as a natural filter. Wastes are taken out by means of a cleansing fluid called dialysate, which is washed in and out of the abdomen in cycles through a surgically placed soft plastic tube (catheter).
"You can do hemodialysis at a dialysis center where a nurse or technician performs the tasks required during treatment," says Dr. Kerry Willis, Senior Vice President for Scientific Activities at the National Kidney Foundation. "You can also do hemodialysis at home where you and a care partner are the ones doing your treatment. At home, you may be better able to fit your treatments into your daily schedule."
In addition to the convenience, "many reports indicate that people using daily home hemodialysis take less medication to control blood pressure and anemia, feel better during dialysis and less ‘washed out' afterward, and have more energy for daily tasks," Dr. Willis pointed out.
However, it has been suggested that better health outcomes may simply be the result of healthier patients opting for home treatment.
In their article, Dr. Victoria A. Kumar and her associates at the Southern California Permanente Medical Group in Los Angeles tested this theory by comparing one group of patients treated with daily home hemodialysis with a group of patients treated with peritoneal dialysis. Home dialysis was performed on average 5.4 times per week.
Dr. Kumar's group treated the 22 patients in the daily hemodialysis group and the 64 in the peritoneal dialysis group for at least 6 months between 2003 and 2007. The groups were comparable in age, the number of patients with diabetes, and causes of kidney failure.
Despite these similarities, patients treated by peritoneal dialysis spent nearly twice as many days each year in the hospital compared with patients treated with home hemodialysis (average 5.6 days/patient-year versus 3.3 days/patient-year).
Those treated by daily home hemodialysis were also able to reduce the number of medications required to keep their blood pressure under control, and had better nutritional status than they did prior to starting treatment, as shown by higher serum albumin levels.
Dr. Kumar and her associates point out that their organization could support the program of home hemodialysis because the cost of equipment, supplies, and patient training was offset by lower expenditures for hospital care and medications.
Unfortunately, many patients do not have the option of home dialysis because Medicare does not fully reimburse health care providers for the costs associated with such a program and not all dialysis centers offer education and training for home hemodialysis. Another challenge relating to home hemodialysis is the need for a care partner.
"If the costs of providing more frequent hemodialysis treatments do not pose a financial burden on the Medicare system," Dr. Kumar and her associates state, "the modality should be freely available to motivated patients with end-stage renal disease."
http://www.kidney.org/news/ekidney/october08/HDvsPD%20_october08.cfm
I Hate Dialysis Message Board
Author
