Please check with your nephrologist before taking anything new.
The problem with some of these protein supplements is that they may not include all the necessary amino acids and in the correct ratios to work correctly for people on hemodialysis. Many times they are not derived from "high quality" protein, which comes from animals, such as eggs, beef, chicken and fish. Whey protein is one of the best sources for supplementation and has a complete amino acid profile.
Also the cost per serving of protein is pretty cheap with whey. Mine is roughly .40 cents a serving (23 grams protein)
I printed out the info that Maggie and Jeff put on here to talk with my people about but I also have not heard of "whey", could someone explain?
The protein supplement my naturopath suggested is SON formula. She says it's superior to whey as more of it is readily absorbed (99%) versus (84%).
My dietician thought it looked good but she worried that I'd have to forego dietary protein altogether.
I went to their site. Overloaded with information, which makes me a bit skeptical. One of the most important facts missing is a list of the amino acids included and at what amounts.All proteins are made up of amino acids, but not all proteins are "complete" proteins, which is determined by which amino acids are included and at what amounts. There are supplements out there which are "incomplete proteins" and are less effective with those on a limited diet such as the renal diet.All I am saying is buyer beware--especially persons on dialysis.
BV= 104PD= 100NPU= 92Biological Value 104 BV is the proportion of absorbed protein that is retained in the body for maintenance and or growth.The BV calue of egg protein is defined as 100Adapted from the Nutritional Quality of Proteins, European Dairy Association 1997Protein Digestibility PD the proportion of food protein absorbed.Net Protein Utilization NPU is the proportion of protein intake that is retained. (calculated as bv x pd)
The dietician at my unit recommended I try a protein supplement but will only approve Healthy 'n Fit 100% Egg Protein powder.
It is difficult sometimes to juggle all this stuff--consuming enough protein (1.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day) without going over phosphorus and potassium restrictions.
Its EAS 5 pounds for just over $30.00. Phosphorus isnt listed. Potassium is 140mg a serving. Figure Phosphorus is roughly the same as other whey powders as my labs havent changed from when I have used other whey products.
Quote from: Zach on September 28, 2008, 04:04:13 PMIt is difficult sometimes to juggle all this stuff--consuming enough protein (1.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day) without going over phosphorus and potassium restrictions.That is why Maggie likes these pills so much it lets her eat other things she likes without going over phosphorus and potassium restrictions.
One will also have to weight the cost factor.24 grams of protein from those pills will run $5.00 compared to protein powder being less than .50 cents for that same serving of 24 grams of protein.