You seem to have caught a bad case of xxxxx Disease, whose main symptom is that you direct personal criticisms at people posting messages, which is strictly forbidden in any polite, civilized discussion and also on this message board. Given the time you have spent in academia, I would expect you to appreciate that while the content of messages can and should be challenged, posters have no business in making inferences or criticisms about the people posting messages. I never have done that, and I expect you to extend me and everyone else on the message board the same courtesy.