Even if you assume that God exists, it is extremely difficult to determine which human tragedies could be consistent with his 'higher purposes' or not, since he has to be assumed to be an entity more weird than our wildest nightmares, given the horrors he imposes on innocent children by the tens of thousands every day. Just consider what his purposes might be in the case of infants born with Hutchinson-Gilford's Disease, which causes them to age very rapidly, so that by the time they are teenagers they have cataracts, arthritis, two hearing aids, thick glasses, complete baldness, numerous diseases characteristic of 80-year-olds, and the appearance of a tiny plucked chicken, as it has been described. On top of this, God gives them an extraordinarily rapidly developing intellect, so they can savor with exquisite torture the full horror of what they are experiencing, until they die of a heart attack, usually around age 20. Can anyone tell me what the divine purpose of this is?
Quote from: stauffenberg on September 09, 2007, 02:43:51 PMEven if you assume that God exists, it is extremely difficult to determine which human tragedies could be consistent with his 'higher purposes' or not, since he has to be assumed to be an entity more weird than our wildest nightmares, given the horrors he imposes on innocent children by the tens of thousands every day. Just consider what his purposes might be in the case of infants born with Hutchinson-Gilford's Disease, which causes them to age very rapidly, so that by the time they are teenagers they have cataracts, arthritis, two hearing aids, thick glasses, complete baldness, numerous diseases characteristic of 80-year-olds, and the appearance of a tiny plucked chicken, as it has been described. On top of this, God gives them an extraordinarily rapidly developing intellect, so they can savor with exquisite torture the full horror of what they are experiencing, until they die of a heart attack, usually around age 20. Can anyone tell me what the divine purpose of this is?We live in an imperfect world where good and evil co-exist. There is a God, the source of all good things, who loves us too much to intentionally hurt His creation. There is also an enemy of mankind who by contrast, hates us and is the source of every unexplainable horror here on the earth. God does not teach us through bad experiences; He teaches us through His words, handed down through time. Religion has used the spectre of a punishing God to control people. If earth was free of troubles, it would be called Heaven.
(My disease is autoimmune, so kidney transplant is most likey not an option).
Quote from: lcamanini on September 11, 2007, 10:51:19 PM(My disease is autoimmune, so kidney transplant is most likey not an option). What autoimmune disease do you have? I have had 2 kidney transplants so far, and I also have an autoimmune disease, so that's why I am asking.
Quote from: angela515 on September 12, 2007, 11:36:17 AMQuote from: lcamanini on September 11, 2007, 10:51:19 PM(My disease is autoimmune, so kidney transplant is most likey not an option). What autoimmune disease do you have? I have had 2 kidney transplants so far, and I also have an autoimmune disease, so that's why I am asking.Me too! I was diagnosed with FSGS. I also had a transplant.