Canadians desperate for transplants turn to illegal organ trade

[okarol]

Canadians desperate for transplants turn to illegal organ trade
CTV National News: Buying organs overseas
 
Canadians who seek kidney transplants are buying them from living donors in poor countries. Medical Specialist Avis Favaro has more.

CTVNews.ca Staff
Published Saturday, June 1, 2013 9:54PM EDT
Last Updated Saturday, June 1, 2013 11:27PM EDT

Canadians desperate for organ transplants are travelling overseas for black market organs, but doctors back home warn that they could be putting their lives at risk.
Driven by a shortage in Canada of living organs, particularly kidneys, patients are turning to the illegal organ trade in countries like India, Pakistan and the Phillipines.
Matin Khan is one of them. Khan endured years of dialysis as she waited for a kidney transplant -- and then paid $10,000 to buy a kidney in Pakistan.
RELATED LINKS
Documentary: Tales from the Organ Trade
PHOTOS
 
Shortage of organs for transplant is forcing Canadians to fly abroad to buy kidneys in foreign countries.
 
A Canadian film documented how people in the Philippines are selling their kidneys for cash.
 
Dr. Jeffrey Zaltzan speaks about organ transplants to CTV News on Saturday, June 1, 2013.
 
Kidney transplant patient Matin Khan speaks about her kidney transplant to CTV News on Saturday, June 1, 2013.
But shortly after returning to Canada, the kidney began to fail, and she became ill.
“I had pneumonia and a fever,” she said. “And I went to the hospital and they found out that the kidney was not functioning anymore.”
Khan is one of a growing number of people worldwide who are taking matters into their own hands. According to the United Nations, approximately 10,000 illegal kidney transplants are being performed worldwide each year.
But Dr. Jeff Zaltzman, a kidney specialist at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto, says patients like Khan are putting themselves at risk.
People who undergo an overseas transplant are often already sick by the time they sent back home, he said.
“They come right to the emergency room requiring hospitalization,” Zaltzman told CTV News. “This has happened on more than one occasion.”
Despite her close call, Khan went back to Pakistan to buy a second kidney. This time, it is functioning well.
Others have not been as fortunate. Some overseas transplant recipients have died, Zaltzman said.
“My greatest fear is that more harm is maybe being done in a number of patients than potentially good,” he said.
The decision to turn to the overseas black market is driven by a critical shortage of organs for transplant, poverty and by so-called black market brokers who seek profit.
A Canadian film has documented how impoverished people in the Phillippines are selling their kidneys for $1,500, sometimes less.
Ric Esther Bienstock, director of “Tales From the Organ Trade,” says she was witnessed firsthand the dangers of such transactions.
“The more you try and crack down, the further underground the black market goes,” she said. “And what is happening is operations are becoming more dangerous for both the recipients and for the people who are selling their kidneys.”


Read more: http://www.ctvnews.ca/health/canadians-desperate-for-transplants-turn-to-illegal-organ-trade-1.1307227#ixzz2V3Qo5Sr0

[Rerun]

Then MAKE IT LEGAL in Canada to buy an organ!  Then I would only have 150 miles to drive!  Plus they would keep the money in Canada to raise their economy.  AND it would get the rich people off the ever growing LIST.

Again I say.... why not pay a young college student with $50,000 in student loans for one kidney.  He will live a perfectally normal life and have to go through ALL the same evaluations as if he were doing it for free.  Everyone else gets a huge payment for doing a transplant.  Why not give the donor a dollar or two. 

Put a price on it.  Then let those who can PAY. 

They put a price on going to the moon.  Those who can .... take the ride.  Nothing wrong with simple economics.  Demand / Supply.

           

[Emerson Burick]

Then MAKE IT LEGAL in Canada to buy an organ!  Then I would only have 150 miles to drive!  Plus they would keep the money in Canada to raise their economy.  AND it would get the rich people off the ever growing LIST.

Again I say.... why not pay a young college student with $50,000 in student loans for one kidney.  He will live a perfectally normal life and have to go through ALL the same evaluations as if he were doing it for free.  Everyone else gets a huge payment for doing a transplant.  Why not give the donor a dollar or two. 

Put a price on it.  Then let those who can PAY. 

They put a price on going to the moon.  Those who can .... take the ride.  Nothing wrong with simple economics.  Demand / Supply.

I think we should also be allowed to hunt humans. Put a price on it. Then let those who can PAY.

I have money. Why shouldn't I be able to slit the throat of an unemployed mommy in front of her children? Nothing wrong with simple economics.

[Hemodoc]

If you take a look at the illegal organ trade and what happens to the "vendors" in Iran, Pakistan and other 3rd world nations, the deal does not improve their economic status and they do end up with significant health deficits. It is my disease and I must deal with it. To remain ethical, living donor organ donation must be voluntary. The example of harvesting organs from prisoners in China is the slippery slope of the illicit organ trade. Is that really where we wish to go?

[bevvy5]

I'm not disputing the article but I don't think it's how, for the most part, we Canadians want to roll. We're pretty proud of our social medicine system up here - it's not perfect, but there have been organizatoins, companies who have tried to set up private medical clinics so those that can afford it can jump the queue.  It doesn't sit that well, frankly.

To me, its on the same level as human trafficking.  It's taking advantage of people who may see absolutely no othr option.

I am putting my soapbox back in the closet.

[monrein]

I agree with Hemodoc and with Bevvy also.  As a Canadian, I have had very good experiences with our health care system.