l. I took the "arm the faculty and staff" suggestion straight to mothers of six and seven year olds from 3 different countries, and the response was less than supportive.
Quotel. I took the "arm the faculty and staff" suggestion straight to mothers of six and seven year olds from 3 different countries, and the response was less than supportive. Asking the mothers of kids for their "expert" opinion is like getting advice from a sick person on what antibiotic they need (if any), or asking a defendant in a criminal trial about legal strategy. "Involvement" does not make one an expert. I can quote several police officers who would favor arming properly trained teachers. The unions would love it because it would no doubt require a pay differential.
WOW, Caraid, how insulting to this guy who may be a parent too. Lots of parents may think just like him. That is where the problem is, they don't all Agree with you and your husband.Really? You have your opinion so don't call his opinion crazy.
Gothic, you are really making sense today..... what are you drinking? I want some.LOL LOVE you!
Quote from: Rerun on December 17, 2012, 09:24:28 AMWOW, Caraid, how insulting to this guy who may be a parent too. Lots of parents may think just like him. That is where the problem is, they don't all Agree with you and your husband.Really? You have your opinion so don't call his opinion crazy.I did not call his opinion crazy, so please don't scold me for something I did not do. I have been called crazy twice in recent memory on this site (not by SimonDog, to be clear) so I would appreciate a bit of consistency if mods are going to call me out for voicing my feelings. I was following SD to an extent until he compared a group of mothers to other examples of ignorant people. How does he know I wasn't talking to mothers who are also security experts themselves? I am a little surprised that you did not pick up on the irony of saying that asking these mothers would be like asking a patient what antibiotic they should take. I tell doctors all the time which antibiotic I should take! That's rather the point of IHD, isn't it?
Quote from: cariad on December 17, 2012, 09:43:16 AMQuote from: Rerun on December 17, 2012, 09:24:28 AMWOW, Caraid, how insulting to this guy who may be a parent too. Lots of parents may think just like him. That is where the problem is, they don't all Agree with you and your husband.Really? You have your opinion so don't call his opinion crazy.I did not call his opinion crazy, so please don't scold me for something I did not do. I have been called crazy twice in recent memory on this site (not by SimonDog, to be clear) so I would appreciate a bit of consistency if mods are going to call me out for voicing my feelings. I was following SD to an extent until he compared a group of mothers to other examples of ignorant people. How does he know I wasn't talking to mothers who are also security experts themselves? I am a little surprised that you did not pick up on the irony of saying that asking these mothers would be like asking a patient what antibiotic they should take. I tell doctors all the time which antibiotic I should take! That's rather the point of IHD, isn't it?When I'm acting as a Moderator I will sign it as that. Otherwise I'm just a member and the whole staff knows that if I have to stop speaking my mind I stop helping Moderate this site, and maybe you could do it. I was pointing out what came to my mind. Probably because I agree with having at least the principal packing. And pilots should pack as well. IMO.
MM I dont know if this is a good answer, but i have one My dad has guns, lots of guns, you could say hes a gun collector... He keeps them locked in a heavy duty safe. He loves to hunt, so most of them are the rifles? i think thats what they are called. but he also has hand guns. One I know he has for security lol the others are heirlooms? passed down from other family members... Now, you asked why anyone would 'need' a gun like that? I dont really think they do, because you can protect yourself just as easily with a rifle, or hell, even a muskette. People did that for a long time, didnt they? But it is a faster weapon. if your busy loading while someone is trying to hurt you or your family, your screwed. My dad is a good man, and loves his guns, it would be sad to see someone take that away. I personally stand on the side that if a criminal wants a gun, they will find a way, gun control or not... And if the government cant protect us, or refuse to, then we have to be able to protect ourselves. And who knows, might have to protect ourselves from them! And I do agree with both on the case of the shooter. I think what I said was both right and wrong. We do need those questions answered, but not in the way that totally makes the guy memorable. I guess I said that right... And we do need more mental health funding. Its really unfortunate, that we have doctors without boarders willing to go overseas to help for free, but none here helping like that. instead, its expensive! Ive been dealing with mental health facilities since i was 11, and I personally dont see that they do much good anyway. Most of the people ive seen arent that great at what they do. (of course I go to the cheap places... i think maybe thats the problem lol) A good one would cost me an arm and a leg, and doubt insurance would cover it. My brother recently lost his mind, and his insurance only covers like 6 visits a year, something he definitely needs A LOT more of! Hes batshit crazy...There will always be people like this, killing innocent people. Their reasoning can be anything, and the result wont change. Some people just suck. Some people cant be helped, Some dont want to be helped. And having gun control or better mental health programs probably wont change that, there are other weapons, other ways...
It wouldn't hurt to take this Adam kid even though he is dead and hang him from the highest tree and let his body rot. Now, again, I know this will not happen but it use to in the old west. Maybe would make a mental case think twice if there were more consequences. I mean this guy who killed people hunting down Gabby Giffores..... IS still going to have a Trial? What the heck for? He should be publically, National TV and all, SHOT.... starting with his dick and going down then up. There are no consequences for these mental cases. Oh, poor boy had a mother who loved him too much..... Really?
Should we spend more money on mental health for those scared young girls who just want out? Maybe provide a safe place for them to have their babies and not kill them and have to live with that the rese of their lives? I'm just thinking outloud here.
Oh, and did you watch the "Multi-Faith" vigil last night. That was weird! I thought the first guy said it all, then that next guy started singing "Ahhhh LUBBA LUBGBA". I thought it would NEVER end. I bet Obama thought that too. I wonder if the Atheist ever got his chance to get up and say "your kids are dead and there is no heaven... sorry... lights out and that is all". Nice hua?
I also understand the pleasure someone could get from shooting at targets, like in the Olympics or at the firing range. I understand that this is a skill.
These killers seem to be following a pattern. They dress up in military gear, arm themselves to the hilt and go out and mow people down.I have two questions...why does anyone need a firearm like the one Adam Lanza used? Does anyone use a gun like that for hunting? AND:Another common thread is mental illness. These killers clearly are ill, and we need to make sure we are better at identifying and treating these people. I propose a 5% added MHT...a Mental Health Tax levied on all firearm purchases. Since the Federal gov't has no more money and we want to control spending, let the individuals who buy these weapons pay for more/better access to mental health assessments/treatments.
OK to you too Cariad. Uggh we are having such a wind storm. My door wreath almost broke my window! I think my garbage is down!
Quote from: gothiclovemonkey on December 17, 2012, 04:34:15 AMMM I dont know if this is a good answer, but i have one My dad has guns, lots of guns, you could say hes a gun collector... He keeps them locked in a heavy duty safe. He loves to hunt, so most of them are the rifles? i think thats what they are called. but he also has hand guns. One I know he has for security lol the others are heirlooms? passed down from other family members... Now, you asked why anyone would 'need' a gun like that? I dont really think they do, because you can protect yourself just as easily with a rifle, or hell, even a muskette. People did that for a long time, didnt they? But it is a faster weapon. if your busy loading while someone is trying to hurt you or your family, your screwed. My dad is a good man, and loves his guns, it would be sad to see someone take that away. I personally stand on the side that if a criminal wants a gun, they will find a way, gun control or not... And if the government cant protect us, or refuse to, then we have to be able to protect ourselves. And who knows, might have to protect ourselves from them! And I do agree with both on the case of the shooter. I think what I said was both right and wrong. We do need those questions answered, but not in the way that totally makes the guy memorable. I guess I said that right... And we do need more mental health funding. Its really unfortunate, that we have doctors without boarders willing to go overseas to help for free, but none here helping like that. instead, its expensive! Ive been dealing with mental health facilities since i was 11, and I personally dont see that they do much good anyway. Most of the people ive seen arent that great at what they do. (of course I go to the cheap places... i think maybe thats the problem lol) A good one would cost me an arm and a leg, and doubt insurance would cover it. My brother recently lost his mind, and his insurance only covers like 6 visits a year, something he definitely needs A LOT more of! Hes batshit crazy...There will always be people like this, killing innocent people. Their reasoning can be anything, and the result wont change. Some people just suck. Some people cant be helped, Some dont want to be helped. And having gun control or better mental health programs probably wont change that, there are other weapons, other ways...My father was a member of the NRA. He had a couple of collectible handguns. I can understand how someone would enjoy having such a collection.While I don't think I could hunt and kill Bambi, I understand that many people enjoy hunting. I do not wish to take away someone else's freedom to do this just becuase I don't like it.I also understand the pleasure someone could get from shooting at targets, like in the Olympics or at the firing range. I understand that this is a skill.What I don't understand is why anyone would need or even WANT a weapon like the one used by this shooter, this "Bushmaster" weapon. This is not a weapon what you can conceal/carry, so of what use would it be in "self-defense"?I understand from the British print media that the shooter's mother was one of these "survivalists", and that's why she had her own private arsenal. She was preparing for the end of civilization as we know it, so that leads me to wonder if mental illness runs in THAT family.I don't think that any one measure will stop things like this from ever happening again, but if we can save even one more classroom or one more filled cinema complex from tragedies like this, it is worth a try. Just because a measure won't completely solve the problem doesn't mean we should do nothing.@ Rerun, as for tying abortion with gun control, there are already many, many states that have defunded Planned Parenthood or are aiming to do so in an attempt to halt abortions altogether, so if you really want to go there, we should be doing the same with gun control. Those states that are clamping down on abortion should also be clamping down on guns. There...how about that? But we are seeing the opposite...abortion rights are rapidly dwindling while permission to be armed to the teeth is expanding rapidly. Illinois has been the only state that forbids concealed/carry, but a recent federal decision has now mandated that this is unconstitutional and so the state legislature has 180 days to draft legislation making concealed/carry legal in this state. So, rerun, you are way off base in this regard.Abraham Lincoln fervently believed that the blood spilled during the Civil War was God's demand for payment for the blood spilled "from the lash" of slavery. I have not been able to escape the thought that the blood of these babies was spilled because we are going down the wrong path and are allowing these evil weapons to dominate our society. We have willingly misinterpreted the Second Amendment, and we are paying the price. With each massacre, God is trying to tell us something, but we refuse to listen. I always knew that something so gruesome would happen that would force us to change our ways. Newtown may be just that.
Peter if you see a garbage can it is mine.
Wow, so we're really comparing aborting pregnancies to shooting innocent kids in a classroom. Seriously???God is angry at us for abortion, so this is the wake-up call to get us to think serioiusly about it? A madman with a gun??? How does one equate to the other???As a woman who has had CKD and now ESRD being treated w/a transplant, who would have to or have had to abort if I ever got pregnant, I take offense to that. Not only that, it reeks WAAAAAY to much of the mentality of the westboro "baptist" "church". Why would ANYone want to be like them??There is no need to drag abortion into this God-awful tragedy. It has absolutely nothing to do about it.Now, can we get back on track to what this thread is really about?? The tragedy in Newton CT and the victims and families affected by it?KarenInWA