American Idol - what do you think?

[okarol]

Tonight didn't end in Haley's favor, but she handled it like a real pro.
Scotty and Lauren couldn't contain their excitement and were pretty happy. Sweet moment when Scotty won the coin toss to pick if he wanted to perform first or second at the finale, because he handed the choice over to Lauren. What a southern gentleman! Love him!

Next Tuesday is the final performance night and choosing a winner isn't going to be easy.

Who do you want to win? Are you happy with the Idol finalists? Do you think Haley would have been a better finalist than Scotty or Lauren?

[boswife]

Aww, what do i think??  I think it turned out just right!!  I love Scotty and his gentleman ways at all times.  He is a true IDOL of mine.  I also love Lauran and think they were the right choice.  Oh, i think Haley is increadable and has amazing talant, as good as the others, but I still think that America chose right..  WHAT A SEASON!!

[sparklelady]

No offense to anyone, I don't like country. I will not watch now as Haley is gone

[cath-hater]

I stopped watching when they voted off Pia Toscano. 

[lmunchkin]

Well I like all kinds of music if it tastefully done.  I loved it when Haley did that Led Zepplin song!  It sent chills down my spine!  She did a really good job on it too!  I do believe her talent grew from the start. She was always just barely making it!  I really hated to see her go. I'd say Scotty hands down and not just for his voice, but there is a charisma about him that makes good stage presence!  He is polite and reasonably handsome.  I do believe he will win!  Lauren has a great voice with some real good range to it.

lmunchkin    

[boswife]

just to toss this in,,,,,,,,,  Casey was from my home town (no longer live there but did when i was his age  )    I thought we were going to have to love him just cause of that but we loved him for his talent too. Weather ya liked his style or not, he is amazingly talented!   I saw some other  increadably talented people leave too soon including Pia..WOW! I cried when that last guy left too (dang, cant even remember is name cause we had our nicnames for everyone so dont even know most of their real names) I kinda thought he may win even.  Again, not my style of music, but sang everything beautifully..............  IMHO of course 

[phyl1215]

Country is not my very favorite music but I picked Scotty from the beginning, he has real talent.  Actually they all had great voices this year, I think the best year.  I believe the top 10 will all have a good shot at stardom.

[lmunchkin]

I forgot about Pia.  She was fantastic and I really thought she left way too soon! I missed it when she was voted out. And the next week we didnt see her and my husband asked where she was and I told him she must have been voted off!  I felt she deserved to be in the end! I couldnt think of her name, so thanks Boswife, for bringing her name up.  Yea, she was a special young lady and attractive to boot!

lmunchkin