2009 American Idol Show

[TynyWonder]

Is anyone following the show American Idol this year?   I am, but I am finding it to be a bit boring or slow for some reason............if you are watching it, how do you feel about it?   Have you made your "pick" yet?

[paris]

I don't like the new format.  Like you, I think it is moving kind of slow and I don't feel like I know the contestants very well.   I am not wild about the new judge.  But, I watch AI every season.  We'll see what happens next week.

[paul.karen]

I'm a guy.
Am i alllowed to watch
I also dont care for the new format.  And it is sad cause some of the people that arnt making it should make it IMO.
With that said i do agree with the picks so far.  But also think at least three others should have made it.
What i DONT like is ALL the commercials, please give me a break.
The new judge for me is still up in the air.
I do wish they would let Simon talk and stop interrupting him.

Ps.  Survivor tonight

[twirl]

I loved it the first couple of seasons
I do not care for the new judge and three judges did a better job ---- not ties   2/2
I find it hard to get interested in this year and last year too
seems as if they talk too much between constestants
they did not need to change the format

[Wenchie58]

I wont start watching til they get down to the top 10...or 5  lol

Short cuts work for me

[TynyWonder]

I too, am still up in the air about the new judge, Kara.........also, I think there were one or two that could have been put through to Hollywood.   However, I was sooooo glad to (well I knew she would go) see that Tatiana girl go, she was very annoying and even the whole time up there on stage last nite, the girl was fiddling with her hair?  Also, that was kinda mean to put her up against Danny who was about the only one who did an outstanding job Tuesday night, ya know?  Did you notice they kept showing her even while Danny sang his song?  She was boo hooing and not even clapping for him like the others that got kicked off were.  I also agree they need to let Simon speak more, I mean come on, be for real, he makes the show............you either love him or you hate him, but people STILL want to hear what SIMON SAYS!     I personally love Simon!