Rachael you raise a valid point. It is true that we do tend to "take the side" of the person posting - I guess because we simply have no other view of the situation, and someone posting here in obvious frustration at what they see from their loved one, is obviously going to influence those of us that are all about doing the best you can for yourself (as a patient) - or if you like, being "compliant"(but I hate that word because it has somewhat negative connotations to my way of thinking). I know when I have read/been involved with(at least as a poster here) some of the situations you alude to, I try to balance the needs of both parties involved. Caring for someone who seemingly won't care for themselves can be very difficult on a number of levels - specially if you try to help as best you can and get nowhere, it can then be counterproductive emotionally.However I agree that it's a very biased issue, and we do not hear from the other side, so is unfair in a way. I guess as a community member of IHD we do try and support everyone here. I don't know about telling people to leave relationships or situations - I think the most I usually suggest is to ensure a person takes time for themselves - as in look after their emotional needs kind of thing.I suppose my own perspective as a renal patient has always been to do the best I can for myself - both while on D and now with the gift of a transplant, so it's difficult for me to understand the kind of mindset that someone may be in to almost deliberately go against medical recommendations as to what would be the best for them. I understand that things like depression and a wish to have some form of control over one's situation, or something like that could lead to someone ignoring things like diet/fluid control etc. I know how difficult it can be for some to adjust to the kidney failure "routine" and I take from your post a thought to be more considerate of such issues - even though I don't personally understand it I surely don't deny these things exist.
I really do agree with taking the side of the renal patient and it is true we are very fatigued, drained, and miserable after treatment....but these the comments confuse me because sometimes we take the side of the renal patient and other times we say, "Heck yeah leave the sick person if they aren't fulfilling your needs." sorry IHD family I just keep thinking about the post from the lady who was bashing her sick husband saying "he wouldn't do this or that , or help himself" etc... and basically everyone took her side saying "you should leave, don't drown with him." It just rubs me the wrong way because at the end of the day this is a debilitatiing disease with no cure....sorry I should just stay away from posts like this.....
Quote from: rsudock on December 09, 2011, 06:33:43 PMI really do agree with taking the side of the renal patient and it is true we are very fatigued, drained, and miserable after treatment....but these the comments confuse me because sometimes we take the side of the renal patient and other times we say, "Heck yeah leave the sick person if they aren't fulfilling your needs." sorry IHD family I just keep thinking about the post from the lady who was bashing her sick husband saying "he wouldn't do this or that , or help himself" etc... and basically everyone took her side saying "you should leave, don't drown with him." It just rubs me the wrong way because at the end of the day this is a debilitatiing disease with no cure....sorry I should just stay away from posts like this.....Rachel, I had problems with that post, too. On the one hand, as Richard said, you only know one side and if someone will do NOTHING for themselves, then that is essentially holding a caregiver hostage and saying 'I will die if you don't do everything for me'. However, I felt there was much more to the story than we were hearing, but obviously have no evidence. To be honest, if someone does not want to stay in a relationship for whatever reason, fair or not, it does not do any service to the people involved to scold the person who wants out and try to get them to stay in the relationship. You cannot make anyone, including yourself, love someone. The weight issue really ticked me off as that was so judgmental of renal patients, and coming from someone who has never experienced ESRD before, I certainly felt it required a response from someone who had, and who has also researched the obesity myth to death. The rest of it, I felt she had already made her decision and really just wanted to hear that she had a right to put herself first. I think in the end, if that's what one person wants, it is best for everyone to just rip the bandage off all at once and move on. I was really depressed through some of the ESRD nonsense and I was lucky that my husband was pretty great about it. Not always, and definitely he did not really understand my emotions and decisions in the pre-transplant phase, but he never talked about leaving. Though we may not be able to take every renal patient's side, rest assured that we will always be on YOUR side, hun.