I Hate Dialysis Message Board
Off-Topic => Off-Topic: Talk about anything you want. => Topic started by: Hephs-little-lady on July 06, 2006, 02:59:31 PM
-
???
This is a story about three people (A, B a C) crossing a desert. A hated C and decided to kill him - he poisoned the water in his sack (only C had water). B also wanted to kill C (not knowing that the water of C had been already poisoned) and so B made a hole into the sack of C and the water spilt out. A few days later C died of thirst.
Who was the murderer - A or B? ;)
-
B was the direct murderer. A attempted murder, but he did not succeed since the poison ran out.
-
Who did what? when? how? and why? you know me, doesnt take much to confuse me ??? I NEED A DRINK....
-
Who knows? I think B did it becasue he caused the water to run out of Cs bag.
Do you why six does not like seven?
Wait for it....
Because seven eight nine (seven ate nine) . LOL >:D
-
???
This is a story about three people (A, B a C) crossing a desert. A hated C and decided to kill him - he poisoned the water in his sack (only C had water). B also wanted to kill C (not knowing that the water of C had been already poisoned) and so B made a hole into the sack of C and the water spilt out. A few days later C died of thirst.
Who was the murderer - A or B? ;)
Okay........who done it?
-
I haven't looked at the answer yet, but have been pondering the scenario for a few days.
??? OK, so A poisoned C, but technically B saved his life by draining the water out of his sack, right? If none of them had water surely all of them would of died after a few days!
So maybe B killed A & C :-\
Or was A responsible for killing B & C by poisoning the water? :-\
But then B drained it out not knowing it was poisoned. ???
So many possibilities.
:D
-
Maybe C killed A and B after he found out his bag was empty, then he dies from lack of water.
Evil minds are working!
-
There's a lot of holes in the desert. A lot of problems resolved there. Speaking of Vegas. >:D
-
There's a lot of holes in the desert. A lot of problems resolved there. Speaking of Vegas. >:D
:secret; Well Sluff, i dont think we will have to go through with our "plan" cuz that "chick" from Oz isnt going to Vegas >:D :banghead;
-
There's a lot of holes in the desert. A lot of problems resolved there. Speaking of Vegas. >:D
:secret; Well Sluff, i dont think we will have to go through with our "plan" cuz that "chick" from Oz isnt going to Vegas >:D :banghead;
:rofl; :rofl; :rofl; and I already have the hole dug.
-
There's a lot of holes in the desert. A lot of problems resolved there. Speaking of Vegas. >:D
:secret; Well Sluff, i dont think we will have to go through with our "plan" cuz that "chick" from Oz isnt going to Vegas >:D :banghead;
:rofl; :rofl; :rofl; and I already have the hole dug.
You know, it would have to be verrrrry deeeeep, i heard them aussie chicks can jump like a kangaroo, and i wouldnt want her escaping :popcorn;
-
I hope your not talking about me susie!! >:D
-
I hope your not talking about me susie!! >:D
Who? Huh? Wha? Me? Neverrrrrrr, *shakes head* no way Jose, nope, nope, nope, (is she still here? is she still reading?) Amanda, you know i luvz ya girlfriend ::) :cuddle;
-
what first you try to kill me... now your saying you luv me.... oh woman make up your mind.!!!!! :lol;
-
what first you try to kill me... now your saying you luv me.... oh woman make up your mind.!!!!! :lol;
:rofl; :rofl;
-
what first you try to kill me... now your saying you luv me.... oh woman make up your mind.!!!!! :lol;
Where on God's green earth did you ever hear that i was trying to kill you?? Please tell me!!! show me!!! prove it to me!!! (polishing gun) ::)
-
Run! Goofy got out the AK47!
-
hey, u leave her alone! ! ! She liked my hair! :bandance;
we need a smiley with great looking hair. :rofl;
so is there an answer to this riddle or what, cuz it seems obvious or did i miss it. ???
<--------Yea know, blonde here. ;)
-
It had to be B because he had intent and did the dirty deed, and A just put poison in the water, C did not die of poison, but of thirst. Poor guy.
-
hey, u leave her alone! ! ! She liked my hair! :bandance;
we need a smiley with great looking hair. :rofl;
so is there an answer to this riddle or what, cuz it seems obvious or did i miss it. ???
<--------Yea know, blonde here. ;)
Afro on the way. O0 just for you.
-
Caution a lot of swearing.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JD44ouab5pc
-
I just love Joe Pesci :2thumbsup;
-
hey, u leave her alone! ! ! She liked my hair! :bandance;
we need a smiley with great looking hair. :rofl;
so is there an answer to this riddle or what, cuz it seems obvious or did i miss it. ???
<--------Yea know, blonde here. ;)
See Susie even tubes is defending me.. thanks tubes!! ;)
And i do not get it either... and I'm not even blonde!! lol
-
How about the answer to the riddle?
-
Yeah, what's the answer? C'mon, give it up! 8)
-
Heph's Little Lady, please answer the riddle for us!
-
I think it was D in the drawing room with a candlestick. ever play Clue?? :waving;
-
I think it was Mr. Mustard in the conservatory with a rope.
-
I think it was Mr. Mustard in the conservatory with a rope.
:rofl; :rofl; :rofl;
-
Heph's Little Lady hasn't posted since July. So does this mean we'll never get an answer to the riddle. I HATE that because now I'll sit around all day trying to figure the darn thing out. And I'm terrible at riddles. :banghead;
HLL - Please come back and tell us the answer!!!
-
B
-
General consensus seems to be that it was B since C died of thirst, not poison.
-
okarol, I see your logic, but...did B really "kill" C? Just by poking a hole in the water sack, C didn't die. C died because of a lack of water; if B had consumed all of the water himself (assuming that he didn't know it had been poisoned), and C had died of thirst, would B still be considered a suspect? Also, if B had known that A poisoned the water, he could have let C drink it and die. Assuming B wanted C dead, this would have been the perfect crime. But it didn't happen that way, did it?
If C had consumed the water before B poked a hole in the sack, C would have died from the poison. So...did B first save C's life by poking a hole in the water sack? Which means, is A the ultimate killer because A poisoned the water in the first place? Nope, I wouldn't buy that. But, I don't buy that B killed C either.
My vote...there is no murderer. C died of natural causes....but, then, on the other hand, where is Heph's Little Lady? Is she on "the lamb"? Does she know more about this riddle than she's telling? (JUST KIDDING HERE, HLL -- play along with me :rofl; :rofl; :rofl; :rofl;). If Heph's Little Lady shows back up with desert sand in her shoes, we'll know. We'll know. :rofl; :rofl;
-
I say there is no answer BUT if I had to choose, look at how its written out (A, B a C) a is closer to C than B, so a had to do it :rofl;
-
Where is Columbo??? Or Jessica Fletcher??? They could tell us "Who done it".
-
Matlock could figure it out, too -- that is, if it ever goes to trial.
-
Don't forget Perry Mason and his side kick Del... and he always seemed to work pro bono.(free)
-
I'd go with the guy who works for free!
-
B was the direct murderer. A attempted murder, but he did not succeed since the poison ran out.
It had to be B because he had intent and did the dirty deed, and A just put poison in the water, C did not die of poison, but of thirst. Poor guy.
I agree with bajanne and Kitkatz, let's see if this makes any sense:
A and B hated C and decided to kill him.
A poisoned the water in C's sack.
B caused C's water to leak from the sack.
C died of THIRST, not POISONED.
In a courtroom A and B should go to jail: B for C's murder, and A for attempting to kill C.
But since A and B didn't have any water, maybe they died too.
And without any witnesses, is there a case??
I say we kill the guy that wrote this stupid riddle.
-
I say we kill the guy that wrote this stupid riddle.
Should we poison him or poke a hole in his water sack?
-
I say we kill the guy that wrote this stupid riddle.
Should we poison him or poke a hole in his water sack?
:rofl; :rofl; :rofl; :rofl; :rofl;